Medicine Atlas

How Healing Is Practiced
Sign In
Text size
100%
Theme

Medicine Atlas

Disputed Statements

Claims this atlas currently marks as unsettled or as tested and found false. A debated fact is one scholars hold competing positions on; a debunked one has been checked against the record and found not to hold. Both are kept in view rather than quietly smoothed over, with the reasoning that put each one where it stands.

57 statements.

Discovery of Streptomycin, DiscovererOfficially credited to Selman Waksman; Albert Schatz, the graduate student who performed the isolation, later won legal recognition as co-discoverer.

Discovery of Streptomycin, Discoveries

Standing

Concerns Discoverer

Currently States Officially credited to Selman Waksman; Albert Schatz, the graduate student who performed the isolation, later won legal recognition as co-discoverer.

Waksman received sole Nobel credit in 1952; a 1950 lawsuit established Schatz as legal co-discoverer with a share of royalties. See the linked dissent on this fact.

Source Wikipedia: Streptomycin

Diuretic Therapy, Origin Year1497

Diuretic Therapy, Treatments

Standing

Concerns Origin Year

Currently States 1497

Source dates proposed mercurial-compound diuretic use to at least the 16th century, shortly after the 1497 syphilis epidemic in Europe; this is the earliest datable pharmacological diuretic use, not a confirmed first use.

Source Mercurial Diuretic (Wikipedia)

Fresh Frozen Plasma Transfusion, Origin Year1940

Fresh Frozen Plasma Transfusion, Treatments

Standing

Concerns Origin Year

Currently States 1940

The cited source states only that plasma first came into medical use during the Second World War (1939-1945); 1940 marks the early-war period rather than a precisely pinned date.

Source Wikipedia: Fresh Frozen Plasma

Galen, Death Year216

Galen, Healers

Standing

Concerns Death Year

Currently States 216

The eleventh-century Suda lexicon places his death around 199 AD, but a passage in Galen's own treatises refers to events of 204 AD, and Arabic sources suggest he lived into the early third century; modern scholars including Vivian Nutton and Veronique Boudon-Millot favor a date around 216 AD.

Source Wikipedia, Wikipedia contributors

Germ Theory of Disease, Discovery Year1861

Germ Theory of Disease, Discoveries

Standing

Concerns Discovery Year

Currently States 1861

No single year settles the theory. 1861 marks Pasteurs experiments refuting spontaneous generation; Robert Kochs 1876 to 1884 work isolating the anthrax, tuberculosis and cholera bacilli is equally credited with establishing germ causation on a rigorous experimental footing.

Source The Greatest Benefit to Mankind: A Medical History of Humanity, Roy Porter

Germ Theory of Disease, DiscovererCredited jointly to Louis Pasteur and Robert Koch, whose complementary work over the 1860s to 1880s together established the theory; earlier contributors including Ignaz Semmelweis and Joseph Lister are also credited with anticipating or applying its logic.

Germ Theory of Disease, Discoveries

Standing

Concerns Discoverer

Currently States Credited jointly to Louis Pasteur and Robert Koch, whose complementary work over the 1860s to 1880s together established the theory; earlier contributors including Ignaz Semmelweis and Joseph Lister are also credited with anticipating or applying its logic.

Historians credit Pasteur and Koch jointly rather than a single discoverer; Semmelweis and Lister are recognized forerunners whose own work preceded formal acceptance of the theory.

Source A History of Medicine, Lois N. Magner

Hippocrates, Birth Year-460

Hippocrates, Healers

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States -460

Traditionally dated to about 460 BC, but ancient biographical sources disagree and no contemporary record fixes the year precisely.

Source The Greatest Benefit to Mankind: A Medical History of Humanity, Roy Porter

Hippocrates, Death Year-370

Hippocrates, Healers

Standing

Concerns Death Year

Currently States -370

Traditionally dated to about 370 BC, on the same uncertain ancient biographical basis as his birth year.

Source The Greatest Benefit to Mankind: A Medical History of Humanity, Roy Porter

Hirudotherapy, Origin Year-1500

Hirudotherapy, Treatments

Standing

Concerns Origin Year

Currently States -1500

Source states first recorded use was 3,500 years ago in Ancient Egypt; taken as approximately 1500 BCE, not an exact year.

Source Wikipedia, Wikipedia contributors

Home Hemodialysis, Origin Year1962

Home Hemodialysis, Treatments

Standing

Concerns Origin Year

Currently States 1962

Multiple groups (Boston, London, Seattle, Hokkaido) claimed to pioneer home hemodialysis in the early 1960s; who started it and the exact year is in dispute. This source places the Hokkaido group slightly ahead via Nose's 1962 PhD thesis.

Source Home Hemodialysis (Wikipedia)

Hotel-Dieu de Paris, Founding Year829

Hotel-Dieu de Paris, Medical Institutions

Standing

Concerns Founding Year

Currently States 829

829 is the earliest solid documentary evidence, recording the hospital as a dependency of the Notre-Dame cathedral chapter. Popular later tradition instead credits Bishop Landry with founding it around AD 651, a claim historians treat as legend rather than documentary record.

Source Hotel-Dieu de Paris

Immunology, Origin Period1796 cowpox inoculation credited to Edward Jenner; predated by centuries of documented variolation practice in China and elsewhere

Immunology, Medical Specialties

Standing

Concerns Origin Period

Currently States 1796 cowpox inoculation credited to Edward Jenner; predated by centuries of documented variolation practice in China and elsewhere

The 1796 cowpox trial by Edward Jenner is the credited founding act of vaccination in the clinical record, but variolation, deliberate infection with smallpox scab material, was already documented practice in China by around 1000 CE and was used across parts of Asia and the Ottoman Empire before reaching Britain. Medical historians genuinely debate how much credit belongs to the earlier, less formally documented tradition versus the 1796 experiment that established a scientific method.

Source History of Vaccines: Edward Jenner Overview

Immunosuppressive Therapy, Origin Year1949

Immunosuppressive Therapy, Treatments

Standing

Concerns Origin Year

Currently States 1949

Marks Hench's 1949 introduction of therapeutic corticosteroid dosing (cortisone), the earliest deliberate pharmacological immunosuppression on record; transplant-specific immunosuppression followed in the 1960s.

Source Wikipedia, Wikipedia contributors

Insulin Therapy, Origin Year1921

Insulin Therapy, Treatments

Standing

Concerns Origin Year

Currently States 1921

Insulin was isolated in 1921, but Best and Collip's biochemical extraction method, developed within days of each other in early 1922, was what made a purified, clinically usable insulin possible; historians still debate how credit for the discovery should be divided among the four researchers, and 1922 is used by some accounts as the true origin year of insulin as a usable treatment.

Source Wikipedia, Wikipedia contributors

Intrauterine Insemination, Origin Year1793

Intrauterine Insemination, Treatments

Standing

Concerns Origin Year

Currently States 1793

John Hunter's 1793 London case is the earliest reported successful human use; the source itself notes earlier successful attempts likely occurred but were not recorded.

Source Embryo Project Encyclopedia: Intrauterine Insemination

Isolation of Insulin, DiscovererFrederick Banting and Charles Best, University of Toronto, with James Collip and J.J.R. Macleod; credit is genuinely contested.

Isolation of Insulin, Discoveries

Standing

Concerns Discoverer

Currently States Frederick Banting and Charles Best, University of Toronto, with James Collip and J.J.R. Macleod; credit is genuinely contested.

Credited principally to Frederick Banting and his assistant Charles Best, who first isolated a pancreatic extract that lowered blood sugar in diabetic dogs in the summer of 1921; biochemist James Collip then purified the extract to make it safe for human use, and physiology professor J.J.R. Macleod supplied the laboratory the work was carried out in and oversaw it. The 1923 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine went to Banting and Macleod alone, a decision Banting protested publicly by sharing his prize money with Best, prompting Macleod to share his in turn with Collip; who most deserves credit for the isolation remains a genuine, sourced dispute rather than a settled attribution.

Source The Greatest Benefit to Mankind: A Medical History of Humanity, Roy Porter

Laparoscopic Surgery, Origin Year1901

Laparoscopic Surgery, Treatments

Standing

Concerns Origin Year

Currently States 1901

Kelling performed the first laparoscopic procedure on a dog in 1901; Jacobaeus performed the first human laparoscopic operation in 1910. This fact records the 1901 animal-model origin; the 1910 human milestone is a separate, later date.

Source Wikipedia, Wikipedia contributors

Lumpectomy, Origin Year1981

Lumpectomy, Treatments

Standing

Concerns Origin Year

Currently States 1981

Partial removal of a breast lump predates formal validation, but 1981 marks the Veronesi randomized trial establishing breast-conserving surgery (quadrantectomy), the basis of the modern lumpectomy, as an accepted alternative to radical mastectomy.

Source Wikipedia: Breast-conserving Surgery

Mercurial Therapy, Origin Year1496

Mercurial Therapy, Treatments

Standing

Concerns Origin Year

Currently States 1496

Sommariva is often credited as first to use mercury for syphilis, though the source notes he may not have been a physician.

Source Wikipedia, Wikipedia contributors

Moxibustion, Origin Year500 BCE

Moxibustion, Treatments

Standing

Concerns Origin Year

Currently States 500 BCE

Source describes Bian Que as a semi-legendary figure; the year marks the earliest specialist practice on record, not a certain founding date.

Source Wikipedia, Wikipedia contributors